BBCs’ September 6 2012 InBiz podcast this morning had a good piece with Clayton Christensen, The Innovators Dilemna, where Clayton thinks that conventional businesses with their bonus driven mentality, often have the wrong idea about motivating the people how work for them.
Clayton Christensen:
There really is a difference between incentives and motivation. What an incentive is ‘I am going to pay you to want what I want.’ And as along as you pay people to want what you want they do it. The minute you stop paying them, to want what you want, they stop. And they are not motivated to do anything. They were just incentivized to do just that.
What motivation is in contrast, is an engine inside of you, that you are so committed to, that whether you are paid or not, it causes you to want to keep sacrificing and serving for the cause that you’re engaged in.
And so if you want people that are working with you or for you to be motivated, then what you have to do is help them see in the work what it is that causes them to be motivated.
The most important of these is achievement. And then right after that comes recognition, and responsibility, the opportunity to learn, and once I realized that if I can create a company like that my people will be with me regardless of whether we are doing poorly or doing well.
Instead what most managers do is they confuse motivation with incentives and therefore the people that work for them, don’t have those motivators in their lives and you just pay them to want what you want.
End.
I am glad to see this being talked about more in business. I think we need it. Also think it is the most important question to answer before starting a company.
Sep 16, 2012 @ 20:53:25
Thank you for this information in the spirit of Dan Pink 🙂
I also hope that this gets a lot more attention in the business world as it creates a better work environment for everyone!
Nov 04, 2012 @ 16:25:45
thank you very much, i hope business poeple may paid thier attention and as well as government here in south sudan
Mar 06, 2013 @ 17:58:42
more information about the difference between motivatin and incentives sholud be put in coulum wise … will be easy to know better…
Mar 17, 2014 @ 21:39:48
complete nonsense
Apr 01, 2015 @ 13:06:45
Hello there.
I disagree completely with the distinction you make between incentives and motivations: incentives can be intrinsic, and in this case they correspond exactly to what you describe as “motivation”.
Conversely, “I am going to pay you to want what I want.” is a particular kind of incentive, called “monetary incentive” by economists and psychologists.
On my view, incentives and motivation are synonym that you can use interchangeably. The distinction you make is in fact a distinction between monetary incentives/motivation and intrinsic incentives/motivation.
A third kind of incentives exists, called “extrinsic incentives”. It’s all kind of motivation that comes from outside the person: monetary incentives are extrinsic motivation, but social pressure, the fear of being excluded if you don’t behave “the right way”, etc. are all extrinsic incentives, that are not monetary.
Thanks for your post.
Mar 24, 2016 @ 00:32:23
Life is a journey